The Father-Shaped Hole: A Journey Through Loss, Identity and Healing

There’s an ache I’ve come to understand deep within myself, a feeling that for years defied easy words. Then I heard it described, with startling clarity, as a hole in my soul—a hole in the shape of my father. That metaphor struck a chord, resonating with a truth I hadn’t fully articulated: The persistent echo of absence. It wasn't just a general sadness, but a void contoured precisely by the role occupied, the role never quite filled.

My soul doesn’t feel marked by a single absence, though, but more like a complex landscape shaped by the presence, absence and shifting influences of four different men that occupied the role of “father” in my life: my birth father, my adoptive father and two stepfathers. Each left his own imprint, contributing to a unique internal geography of connection, confusion, loss and longing.

The “hole” isn’t necessarily emptiness for me, but rather a territory mapped by questions. With four figures stepping into that role at different times, the ground beneath my feet often felt unsteady. Who was I in relation to each of them? What did “father” even mean when the definition kept changing?

Instead of one clear shape, it felt like overlapping outlines—moments of connection shadowed by departures, stability offered and then potentially withdrawn.

The space inside me feels molded by this very multiplicity. There’s the void left by my birth father, carrying questions of origin and belonging. There’s the relationship with my adoptive father, the man legally designated as “dad,” bringing its own unique dynamics of love and pain.

Then came my stepfathers, each introducing a new family structure, new hopes for connection, new experiences of adjustment and instability. Each relationship—whether present, absent, loving, difficult or temporary—carved its own contours into my understanding of security, trust and male affection.

Living with this complex father-shaped landscape has inevitably colored my journey. The search for stability became paramount as the bedrock of that paternal role felt like shifting earth. Was I trying to find one person that could embody all the missing pieces from the four? Was I trying to avoid the potential for disappointment altogether?

I became driven to seek validation. It wasn’t just about earning one man’s approval, but about navigating the perceived expectations or judgments associated with each of these figures. Finding my own footing, trusting my own judgment, can feel like a monumental task. I would find myself constantly looking outward for confirmation, unsure of my own internal compass.

Healing, for me, hasn’t been about magically erasing the past or finding a single “answer”. It’s been a messy, ongoing process of untangling the threads. It involves looking honestly at each relationship and its impact, acknowledging the good and the difficult. It requires grieving multiple forms of loss: the loss of the idealized father figure, the loss of stability, the loss of connection.

Here are some approaches that I’ve used that focus on nurturing yourself and building new, healthy ways to address underlying needs:

Practice Self-Compassion                                                                                                                   

Directly address the inner void by practicing self-compassion. Learn to provide yourself with the validation and emotional support that was lacking, which is a powerful step in healing.

Connect With Other Men                                                                                                                   

Combat isolation and meet your needs for belonging by building genuine connections with other men, especially in support groups where shared experiences offer validation.

Seek Professional Support                                                                                                          

Therapy provides a guided space to understand your father issues and unmet needs, helping you process experiences and develop healthier internal resources.

Understand Your Father as an Individual                                                                                            

Gain perspective, rather than change the past. Realize that, like all of us, he is a flawed human being simply doing his best. A low-pressure activity like a walk, or approaching him with genuine curiosity about his life story, can sometimes provide new understanding and context.

Give Back by Supporting Other Men

Once more grounded, supporting other men on their journeys by responsibly sharing your story or mentoring can create a profound sense of purpose and connection.

These approaches focus on building from within and creating new, healthy patterns and connections—a more profound and lasting way to address the sense of a “hole” than seeking temporary or ill-fitting external “fillers”.

Living with this father-shaped hole isn’t about erasing the marks left by these four men. It’s about understanding the edges and depth. The goal no longer is a perfectly smooth, filled-in space, but a life built with consciousness and resilience—finding peace by understanding and embracing my own unique story.

Dan Bulf is a skilled facilitator who designs impactful experiences fostering self-discovery, connection and conscious action. He is a certified facilitator for MenLiving, specializing in crucial topics like death and dying, fatherhood and masculinity. Drawing from his passion as a registered yoga teacher, Bulf employs a connection-based approach, skillfully bringing playfulness and tenderness to even the most challenging conversations. Follow him on Facebook and Instagram at @danbulf.

Read more ...